Let Them Play

As a Public Policy and Law student at Trinity College I have extensively studied Title IX policy. It prohibits sexual harassment and gender-based harassment of all students, regardless of the actual or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity. Under Title IX, transgender girls have the right to play and not face any discrimination or harassment. This right to play does not discriminate against cisgender girls' right to play. 

 

I was happy to see that in Connecticut, the Connecticut Interscholastic Athletic Conference determined trans athletes can play on teams consistent with their gender identity.”

However, although Connecticut has inclusive policies towards transgender student-athletes, not everyone accepts it and transgender student-athletes are still discriminated against and under attack in Connecticut.

 

For example, Selina Soule et al have made use of their interpretation of Title 9 to sue the CT Association of Schools claiming that CIAC’s policy allowing transgender athletes to participate results in transgender girls displacing cisgender girls in competitive track events in Connecticut and robs cisgender girls’ opportunities to compete at higher levels and gain public recognition critical to college recruiting and scholarship opportunities. 

 

Plaintiffs claim that this is discrimination against biologically female athletes as they assert transgender females have physiological athletic advantages over girls. Since Title IX is a law that was designed to eliminate discrimination against women, the plaintiffs claim that allowing trans athletes to compete perpetuates discrimination against “biological” girls. They believe that transgender girls are not “real” girls and therefore Title IX does not apply to them and they are not deserving of an equal competitive opportunity. I think these claims could not be further from the truth.

 

Transgender inclusive policies do not harm cisgender youth. We can look to Canada for an example of this; since 2018 Canadian universities have allowed transgender athletes to compete on teams that correspond with their gender identity with no hormone treatment. U Sports (the national governing body of university sports in Canada) found that there was a serious lack of scientific evidence that hormones significantly impact athletic performance.

 

Studies of testosterone levels in athletes do not show any clear, consistent relationship between testosterone and athletic performance. Transgender girls are not the only girls with high testosterone levels. An estimated 10 percent of cisgender girls have polycystic ovarian syndrome, which results in elevated testosterone levels and those girls are not banned from female sports. 

 

It’s clear that people like Selina Soule and others' desire to ban transgender girls from competing in sports is not about “fairness.” It is about erasing and excluding trans people from participation in all aspects of public life. Transphobic people do this because they believe that their feelings take priority over transgender people's lives. The exclusion of transgender girls from athletics is a form of discrimination that is harmful not only to trans girls but to cisgender girls as well. 

 

Over the years I have watched cisgender black women athletes be criticized for not conforming to society's expectations for femininity (small, white, and petite). Online I see people say that Serena Williams has an unfair advantage against her skinnier white competitors because of her build and strength and even some people claim she was born a man and therefore is not deserving of her titles. There is a long history of racist people trying to discredit the incredible achievements of black women athletes by claiming that they were born a man because they don't fit the “norm” of femininity. 

 

Racist and misogynistic people don't want to see black women be successful at sports, because they're racist and misogynistic. Transphobic people don’t want to see transgender people be successful at sports because they're transphobic. Transmisogyny requires rigorous policing of people's bodies in ways that have less to do with biology or fairness and everything to do with cis people's feelings about how society should be set up. If we allow cisgender feelings to take priority over transgender people, not only will transgender girls be affected but cisgender girls who do not fit the mold of a “traditional” girl will be affected. 

 

In public schools across the country, transgender youth must not be erased or excluded from sports. By denying transgender youth access to sports, courts say “your life, and anyone who does not fit the mold of traditional womanhood, does not matter.” That is HARMFUL. The CIAC ruling that transgender student-athletes are allowed to play sports consistent with their gender should stand and other states should adopt the same policies. If we choose to categorize sports according to gender, the least we can do is respect athlete’s genders. Transgender rights must be prioritized over cisgender feelings. 

Previous
Previous

A Day in Bath

Next
Next

Tough on Crime to Tough on People