Tough on Crime to Tough on People

Close your eyes. Imagine that you are a 17-year-old African American boy. You’re coming home from a party in New York City with a friend and get stopped by police. They are looking for two black men who stole a backpack containing a camera, $700, a credit card, and an iPod Touch. They do not find the backpack on you or your friend, but the person who claimed to be robbed identifies you both as the thieves. Although you claim you are innocent and there is no proof, you are charged with robbery, grand larceny, and assault. Since you’re already on probation from a prior conviction, you are imprisoned at RNDC on Rikers Island, one of the most violent prisons in the world. After getting in fights with several inmates, you are placed in solitary confinement for 2 years. Although your case is extremely straightforward, it is constantly delayed by a backlog of work at the Bronx County District Attorney’s office. You never recover from the trauma of being locked up alone for 23 hours a day and commit suicide at the ripe age of 22.

Now open your eyes. This was the reality for Kalief Browder. Before he committed suicide, he said about prison, “I feel like I was robbed of my happiness.” He spent years of his teenage life in solitary confinement for allegedly stealing a bookbag. He truly was robbed of his happiness and many other prisoners are robbed of their happiness as well.

The framers of the United States Declaration of Independence took inspiration from Philosopher John Locke’s work the Two Treatises of Government where he claims all men have the right to “life, liberty, and property”. Locke further declares that this right is void after one commits a crime; once a criminal “a man so far becomes degenerate and declares himself to quit the Principles of Human Nature, and to be a noxious Creature.”

Locke’s ideas did not only resonate with the framers but resonated with the criminal justice system which focuses more on the stigmatization and dehumanization of convicts rather than attempting to rehabilitate them.

What does it do to one’s mental health if they are locked away, kicked out of society, and seen as a noxious creature? Even if you commit a crime as small as allegedly stealing a bookbag, you are declared no longer a member of society and officially a “noxious creature”.

Being whisked away to prison and seen as a noxious creature can take a serious toll on an individual’s psychological well-being.

In prison inmates’ identities are stripped, they are separated from their loved ones, exposed to violence, and some are placed in solitary confinement like Khalif.

There are an estimated 383,200 inmates with a severe psychiatric disorder in the U.S., over ten times as many as people who are housed in state mental hospitals. Many prisoners who need psychiatric medication do not get that support in prison. Suicide is the leading cause of death in jails.

The Covid-19 pandemic has further worsened mental health for prisoners as they are an extremely vulnerable population. The amount of cases is 5.5 times higher for prisoners than the rest of the general U.S. population and the death rate is a whooping three times higher than the rest of the population.

As Americans recognize the negative effects of social distancing on our mental health, we must also recognize the dehumanizing and isolating experience of incarceration. Social relationships, recreational activities, a safe environment, and access to therapists are necessary to maintain mental health and it is inexcusable to deny these resources to prisoners.

Most people who end up in prison already have issues with substance abuse, mental health, and a considerable amount of trauma going in and then are released back into their communities, further traumatized. Many people in prison need mental help and being in prison just further exacerbates that need. There needs to be more effective mental health services in correctional facilities.

 The way prisons currently treat inmates must be severely reformed. Prisoners are not noxious creatures. They are humans, they are citizens, and they deserve help and rehabilitation.

And most of all, prisoners, specifically black prisoners, deserve justice.

African Americans are incarcerated in state prisons across the country at more than five times the rate of whites. We must recognize that police engage in excessive surveillance, incursion’s on civil liberties, and arbitrary force towards black people in this country. Savage violence from police towards black people, excessive policing in black communities, and unfair sentencing for black convicts is racist and a violation of democracy. Furthermore, it leaves people behind bars and traumatized from our broken prison system.

If Kalief was not been targeted, imprisoned, and unfairly prosecuted, he would still be with us today. Reducing poor mental health for prisoners is not only tied to reforming the prison system and prioritizing the mental health of prisoners but is tied to significant reductions in excessive surveillance and reform of the unfair and racist criminal justice system that led them to be imprisoned in the first place.

Previous
Previous

Let Them Play

Next
Next

The Domestic Extremist Threat: Recap & Review